نقد دلايل مخالفان ضرورت تربيت ديني در نظام آموزش و پرورش رسمي

A Critique of the Reasons Presented by Opponents of the Necessity of Religious Education in the Formal System of Education

مطلوبيت و ضرورت تربيت ديني خواه به صورت كلي يا در نظام آموزش و پرورش رسمي بر اساس متون اسلامي امري انكار ناپذير است. با وجود اين، ترديدها و مخالفت هايي در بارة ضرورت تربيت ديني در نظام آموزش و پرورش رسمي از سوي برخي متفكران غربي ابراز شده كه هدف اين مقاله بررسي و نقد اين دلايل و اثبات مطلوبيت و ضرورت تربيت ديني در آموزش و پرورش رسمي با روش توصيفي، تحليلي و انتقادي است. بي‌معنايي و غير عقلاني بودن آموزه‌هاي ديني و تلقيني بودن تربيت ديني از مهمترين دلايل عام مخالفت با ضرورت تربيت ديني و تلقيني بودن مفهوم تربيت اسلامي دليل خاص مخالفت با ضرورت تربيتي ديني اسلامي است كه در اين مقاله نقد و بررسي مي‌شود. در پايان نيز مطلوبيت و ضرورت تربيت ديني با دلايل جداگانه به اثبات مي‌رسد.

The desirability and necessity of religious education cannot be denied according to the Islamic texts, whether in general or in the formal system of education. Nevertheless, there are doubts and oppositions regarding the necessity of religious education in the formal system of education by some western thinkers. This article aims at investigating and criticizing these reasons and proving the desirability and necessity of religious education in the formal system of education through a descriptive, analytical and critical method. Senselessness and irrationality of religious teachings as well as suggestive nature of religious education are among the most important general reasons for opposition to necessity of religious education, and the suggestive nature of the concept of Islamic education is the specific reason for opposition to necessity of religious-Islamic education. In this article, these reasons are reviewed and investigated. Finally, the desirability and necessity of religious education are proved using separate reasons.